Feedback is one of the hardest parts of being a new manager. And it makes sense: most new managers have never had to give it before.
If you were promoted from peer to leader, it's even harder. There's a little imposter syndrome: "Why would they listen to me?" There's guilt. And if you're not naturally direct, it can feel impossible.
So what happens? New managers avoid hurting anyone's feelings, keep everything positive, and skip the conversation entirely. That's never a good thing.
Start with positive feedback
When we got our dog, we did positive reinforcement training, and it blew my mind. Instead of yelling "no" when she had an accident on the rug, we rewarded what we wanted. Every time she went outside, she got a treat. And it forced us to notice the neutral moments too, like when she was lying quietly and being independent.
I use this with people. Of course you recognize someone who goes above and beyond. But also acknowledge when they're just doing their job well, independently, and things are working.
That tells people they're on the right track, so they keep doing it. Without it, people start to wonder if they're even doing a good job. Or they get resentful because they're never recognized.
Don't put off the hard conversations
Preparing is key. But the anxiety you build up waiting is often the hardest part. The longer you wait, the bigger it feels.
When you have the conversation, deal in facts:
What happened?
What went wrong?
What are the expectations?
What would you like to see done better, and how?
Don't just explain why something didn't work. Give them a clear picture of what success looks like.
The compliment sandwich has a time and place
If it's the first or second time you're giving someone the same feedback, and it's something like an assignment that could have been done better, a compliment sandwich works well. No harm, no foul.
But if it's an ongoing issue that isn't getting resolved, ditch the sandwich. Hidden between compliments, the real message gets lost. Be clear and direct about the issue and how to fix it. (And if it's a serious conduct issue, skip the sandwich from the start.)
Timing matters
Feedback in the moment is great, as long as you can deliver the right message. Sometimes you need a beat to plan. But don't stew on it. Waiting can make it a bigger deal than it is, and the employee may not even remember it.
For bigger performance conversations, wait no more than a week. If schedules or shifts get in the way, figure out the timing, but don't let it slide past a week.
When your direct report used to be your peer
I always recommend having the conversation up front: "I know this is a little awkward. We've worked side by side, and now I'm the one giving direction. I'm really excited about this role, and I think we can take this team somewhere great. Here's where I'll need your help."
Include them in the why and give them real responsibility. People trust leaders who explain how their work fits the bigger picture.
I coached a new manager whose friend, now a direct report, didn't respect the change. They wanted to talk about personal things at work and work things during personal time. So the manager set a boundary: "I really love our friendship, and I don't want that to change. I also really value my job and this promotion. I don't want anyone to think you're treated differently because we're close. Can we keep personal conversations for when we hang out, and work conversations at work?"
Your strengths change how you give feedback
If you're high in Empathy, you'll soften the message, which can be a gift. But it can also lead you to put things off, or let standards slide when you need to hold them.
If you're high in Command, you're clear and direct. Just remember the person on the other side has their own thoughts and feelings. Be direct, and be human.
Because clarity is kindness. Putting it off isn't nice. It just makes it harder for everyone.
Kirsten
PS: I have 3 spots open for Q1 in my leadership program for first time managers. If your managers are struggling with feedback, book a discovery call here.

